The Sovereign Individual - Mastering the Transition to the Information Age - YouTube - PR Report #4 The Sovereign Individual::Chapter 4 - The Last Days Of Politics
This is a summary of Episode 4 of "The PR Report," focusing on Chapter 4 of "The Sovereign Individual," titled "The Last Days of Politics, Parallels Between the Senile Decline of the Holy Mother Church and the Nanny State." The host, Puebl Rising, delves into the authors' analysis of a historical mega-political shift from 500 years ago to illuminate current transitions from the industrial to the information age.
The authors, James Dale Davidson and Lord William Reese-Mogg, argue that we are undergoing a phase change similar to the one that occurred around the end of the 15th century, marked by technological advancements that transformed medieval society. They use the concept of "megapolitics" to identify hidden causes of change that alter the logic of violence and are often overlooked. This understanding aims to help individuals navigate the "new revolution of power" that is shifting power away from nation-states.
The chapter is titled "The Last Days of Politics" because the authors forecast the death of traditional politics, seen as a struggle for control over violence, fueled by the increased returns on violence brought about by the gunpowder revolution. They point out that corruption, moral decline, and inefficiency are signal features of a system in its final stages, drawing parallels between the Church at the end of the 15th century and today's nation-state.
Five hundred years ago, the Church was central to everything, much like politicians and governments are today. The Church, like today's nation-state, had a roughly 500-year run. The Church was plagued by corruption (like the sale of indulgences), immorality (like the clergy's illegitimate children), and inefficiency (like lower clergy members begging for homes). Today, nation-states face similar accusations, with politicians often seen as corrupt and the system as oversized and inefficient, evidenced by continual tax increases and government overreach.
The mega-political shift at the end of the 15th century, driven by technological advancements, spurred a transition from an agricultural, feudal society dominated by the Church to a society of industry, commerce, and exploration increasingly critical of the Church. This transition was catalyzed by gunpowder-based weaponry, the printing press, and improved shipping technology.
Gunpowder-based weaponry increased the scale and returns of violence, leading to a downward pressure on feudalism and a shift in the relationship between individuals and their rulers. It allowed a monarch to purchase more weapons, increase the scale of firepower and increase the returns on your violence. Physical strength becoming less relevant as wealth could be deployed more strategically.
The printing press increased literacy, eroding the medieval worldview of symbolic interpretation and paving the way for critical thinking, cause-and-effect reasoning, and eventually the scientific revolution. It facilitated the spread of knowledge about new markets and investment opportunities, decentralized knowledge, and provided an outlet for criticism of the Church. Much like the internet and technologies like Bitcoin are being targeted for suppression.
Improved shipping led to increased exploration, new trade routes, and the emergence of a merchant class with capital to deploy, leading to new opportunities such as funding armies, spy ships, or expeditions to the New World. This class was less supportive of the Church and preferred to invest in these new ventures.
The modern world was born in the confusion of new technologies, new ideas, and the stint of black gunpowder. Gunpowder weapons and improved shipping destabilized the military foundation of feudalism, even as new communications technology undermined its ideology. The printing press helped reveal the corruption of the Church, a society that was paradoxically held in low regard by a society that placed religion at the center of everything. It is a paradox with an obvious contemporary parallel in the disillusionment with politicians and bureaucrats in a society that places politics at the center of everything.
The analysis helps to cement the understanding that a major mega-political transformation is underway. Much like the ruling system at the center of society, the nation state governments are corrupt, immoral, oversized and inefficient. The rapid evolution of technology has also shifted the logic of violence and finance is shifting again. Now groups and individuals can pose a legitimate threat to a large-scale entity like a nation-state.