The Sovereign Individual - Mastering the Transition to the Information Age - YouTube - PR Report #5 The Sovereign Individual::Chapter 5 - The Life And Death Of The Nation-State
Puebl Rising's PR Report, Episode 5, delves into Chapter 5 of "The Sovereign Individual," focusing on the nation-state's trajectory as it transitions into the Information Age. The chapter, titled "The Life and Death of the Nation State, Democracy, and Nationalism as Resource Strategies in the Age of Violence," examines how these concepts, once strengths, are now being challenged.
The episode opens with a "Tale of Two Walls," drawing parallels between the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 and the destruction of San Giovanni's walls in 1495. The latter marked the advent of the Industrial Age and the rise of gunpowder, ushering in an era where violence and resource extraction were paramount. The former, 500 years later, signifies the shift to the Information Age, where violence diminishes in importance. The key difference highlighted is that in the Industrial Age, nation-states that could consistently deploy violence most successfully thrived. Magnitude trumped efficiency; having the largest army was more critical than its strategic application. To sustain these large armies, states needed to efficiently extract wealth from their citizens, hence the Berlin Wall, preventing citizens from escaping and ensuring continued resource extraction. Even in the West, though expatriation was permitted, it was heavily taxed, demonstrating a less obvious, yet present, control.
The report examines democracy's role in facilitating the gathering of resources into state hands. The US, during the Cold War, excelled in this, effectively "seizing" resources from citizens. The US government is framed as a business where tax revenue, forcibly acquired, funds "full-spectrum security services" demonstrated by its global military presence. This business, however, is run by its employees, the elected officials, who prioritize policies that increase employment, meaning they are less interested in reducing costs or taxes. This inherent conflict of interest leads to chronic deficits as governments prefer to let revenues fall below outlays rather than cut spending due to political repercussions.
Nationalism is identified as a key tool in bolstering state support by emphasizing shared characteristics like language and group identification stemming from state interests. This facilitates larger army mobilization at a lower cost and simplifies bureaucracy. A common language enables faster dissemination and understanding of edicts, streamlining rule and reducing the need for intermediaries. Democracy and nationalism, therefore, greatly improved wealth extraction during the Industrial Age, vital for funding large militaries and prioritizing magnitude over efficiency.
The book asserts that the Information Age will expose the predatory nature of the nation-state. To survive, these states must continue to extract huge amounts of wealth. The report then analyzes recent events within the US, specifically mentioning talk of a proposed tax on unrealized gains, a suggested 15% "Patriot tax" for those with zero income tax liability, and the idea of "Fed accounts" that would allow greater control over finances and enable market intervention by the New York Fed. These proposals, the report argues, support the theory that nation-states are striving to maintain their grip on wealth extraction to maintain current structures.
The current era is characterized by the prioritizing of efficiency over magnitude. The report suggests that nation-states may not survive in their current form because the large militaries they evolved to fund are no longer necessary due to the revolution in micro-processing-based technology. This emphasizes the book's central theme, which is a new revolution of power, a liberation of individuals that comes at the expense of the 20th-century nation-state. Finally, the report ends with a quote from the book, reiterating that new institutional forms must arise, that can preserve freedom within the new technological conditions while also giving expression in life to the common interests that all citizens share.